Don't go, Krom, you're an awesome editor.
Arisboch, a fan
Krom is Oliver Smith. One sad psycho with nothing useful to spend his time on.
Emil Kirkegaard, not a fan

Oliver D. Smith is an ex-RationalWiki editor and sysop from England. He has used various different accounts, most notably Krom in 2015,[1] briefly returning in Feb 2018 as ODS (using his name initials) but no longer is active. Smith is probably the most controversial sysop to have ever edited RationalWiki.

Smith has managed to annoy and offend most religions, political groups and pseudoscientists for his RationalWiki edits; he joined RationalWiki at the beginning of 2012 to criticize religion and later made articles to document and refute various pseudosciences. Although he has been labelled as a skeptic, he doesn't identify with this movement, and has some fringe beliefs himself that are not currently accepted by mainstream science. It is therefore amusing that Smith has been described on some blogs as "attacking" individuals for pseudoscience, when he is open to such criticism himself.



Books made by Oliver D. Smith.

A student of classics (BA, MA), Smith specialises in Greek mythology although this hasn't ever helped his career. He has worked in museum collections, libraries, as an archivist and as a bookbinder. Smith is qualified in bookbinding, having studied for a City & Guilds certificate. He is 28 years old.

Religious views

Smith is a former nontrinitarian Christian, but leaned heavily towards deism and denied most supernaturalism in the Bible; most his views aligned with the Christadelphians.[2] In 2012, he became irreligious and an agnostic deist; Smith considers religion incompatible with his antinatalist beliefs. When formerly a Christian, Smith was a member of a small online group of Christian antinatalists who tried to reconcile antinatalism with the Bible, for example by pointing out that humans were originally asexual and did not know procreation (Gen 2: 22-23; 3: 7) until the Fall, and therefore reproduction is immoral and a sin. Christianity and antinatalism however are incompatible (Gen 1: 28; 3: 16), and after coming to terms with this, Smith gave up religion. His agnostic deism is mostly influenced by ancient Greek philosophy.

Creationism vs. evolution

Smith has always been an outcast for his unusual views on the creationism versus evolution controversy. A critic of orthodox or fundamentalist biblical creationism, Smith formerly identified with progressive creationism and was a proponent of the obscure Revelational Theory of P. J. Wiseman: arguing the Genesis creation account is not a record of what God performed in six literal days but instead records the six literal days (pictorially) in which knowledge of the creation was revealed to man, consistent with modern geology and an old earth. However, when he became irreligious, Smith wrote the RationalWiki article[3] rejecting the theory and came to accept the modern evolutionary synthesis (neo-Darwinianism) and methodological naturalism. For several years, Smith has now criticised creationism as a pseudoscience on RationalWiki, and has debated biblical creationists on forums.

On the subject of human evolution, Smith still has some unorthodox views such as rejecting the Out of Africa theory and wrote the OOA, Assimiliation Model, Polygenism and Multiregionalism hypothesis articles on RationalWiki in 2015.[4] He is also a proponent of the radical "single species hypothesis" that argues ever since humans diverged from chimpanzees about 10 million years ago - there has been only one continuous human species and no speciation. Smith has an interest in transformed cladistics, having written the Wikipedia article.

Sexuality, antinatalism

Smith identifies as Grey-A, somewhere between asexual and heterosexual. He has never been in a relationship and is sexually abstinent. He is pro-LGBTQIA rights, but doesn't like the modern subcultures of these groups. Smith is an antinatalist and is voluntary childfree; he began writing a book on antinatalism a few years back and his antinatalist views are best summarised by David Benatar, “The Misanthropic Argument for Antinatalism". His politics are based on any measure to stop/reverse population growth and are neither strictly left nor right wing.


Smith joined RationalWiki at the beginning 2012 when he had become irreligious, and made articles to document and refute biblical pseudoarchaeology and criticise religion. Later he moved on to criticise irrational beliefs and pseudosciences, e.g. ancient astronauts, dowsing, Bermuda Triangle, spiritualism, creationism and racialism.


Smith is a proponent of the fringe/pseudoscience cryptozoology (from a folklore perspective) which he thinks is fun and he has added some cryptozoological content (e.g. on the Yeti, Bigfoot) to RationalWiki over the years.

Pissing people off


Google search of Oliver D. Smith's name has been abused by trolls who dislike RationalWiki

While some people have praised his contributions on RationalWiki, Smith has managed to piss off and annoy some people with his edits, mostly lunatics and cranks. These people react typically by creating smear articles about Smith on their personal websites to the extent a Google search of his name is abused.


  • Mikemikev: a neo-Nazi troll who has been in a 5 year feud with Smith.
  • Rome Viharo: troll who owns a fake news website about RationalWiki.
  • Abd ul-Rahman Lomax: Muslim who dislikes Smith for his antinatalism.
  • Emil Kirkegaard: alt-right pseudoscientist and cyber-stalker.

See also

External links

Notes & References

  2. Smith rejected the idea that Jesus was God, instead arguing like Christadelphians he was a mortal man, but who overcame temptation (e.g. John 14:28 "my Father is greater than I" and in Heb 5:7-8 Jesus prays to God, making no sense if he was God himself); similar to Christadelphians, Smith argued angels and demons were not supernatural, as well as denied the existence of heaven/hell as an afterlife. Opposing immortality of the soul he favoured "soul sleep" until resurrection, another Christadelphian teaching.
  3. RationalWiki: Revelation Theory of Creation.
  4. RationalWiki: Multiregional hypothesis.